AGF Logo
  • Home
  • Industry and Expert Views
  • Investing and Market Views
  • Capitol Insights
  • Français
  • AGF.com
Skip to content
AGF logo
Insights and Market Perspectives
  • Industry and Expert Views
  • Investing and Market Views
  • Capitol Insights
  • Contributors
  • Français
  • Search
Search
Close
Why ESG Investors Need to Rethink Capital Intensity

  • Investing and Market Views

For Print Only Logo
Insights and Market Perspectives

Why ESG Investors Need to Rethink Capital Intensity

Author: Martin Grosskopf

March 10, 2020

Of the financial market trends since the Great Recession, arguably none has been stronger than the shift in investor sentiment towards businesses that have low capital intensity. These businesses tend to have a significant portion of their market value attributed to intangibles, with resulting high margins and returns on capital, and they comprise large weights within global equity benchmarks. The primary economic trend that benefits these companies is the shift toward services within developed economies. Many economic commentators view this as a sign of improving efficiency; some go so far as to suggest a decoupling from the capital intensity of previous economic cycles.

Investors concerned with environmental, social and governance (ESG) issues might see these market and economic trends as a double benefit. “Asset-light” business models are perceived to have lower emissions intensity, and financial markets reward them handsomely. Within the context of sustainability and climate change, it looks like low capital intensity can help ESG investors enjoy the best of both worlds.

Unfortunately, appearances can be deceiving. To focus on asset-light businesses in support of sustainability goals is to ignore the broader realities of global production networks, as well as the material flows required to support current economic growth and future population increases. It also diverts financial market support away from more capital-intensive industries where emissions reduction can potentially have greater impact. How can this gap between perception and reality be bridged?

First, we must separate fact from hypothesis. If economic growth is decoupling from capital intensity, we should be seeing a decline in inputs as well as outputs such as emissions and solid waste. This is clearly not occurring. In fact, raw material use continues to increase, as shown by the rise in copper consumption per capita, a fair proxy for overall consumption. On the output side, CO2 emissions per capita are increasing; so are waste volumes, not just in emerging economies but in developed countries as well.

Source: World Bank Data as of February 27, 2020

Part of the reason behind the idea of decoupling might be the optimization of supply chains. Capital-intensive resource extraction and manufacturing have been moving to emerging markets – effectively offshoring capex, waste and emissions intensity. In some cases, as little as 5% of supply chain emissions might reside in the country of product origin, with local capex tending to target cloud infrastructure. On the other hand, waste flows provide a window into actual local consumption intensity. As the market most benefiting from asset-light business models, the United States leads in per capita waste generation – at three times the global average, according to Verisk Maplecroft’s Waste Generate and Recycling Indices 2019 report, and at levels higher than other industrialized nations with higher GDP per capita. 

In this regard, the market is a poor arbiter of the actual intensity of a business model even as it begins to push for emissions reductions. One only need look to the increased urban congestion and pollution associated with the rise in ride-sharing services or same-day delivery – industries attracting plenty of investor support – to understand that “decoupling” is often more promise than reality.    

This background is critical to understanding the so-called energy transition needed to meet carbon reduction ambitions. Instead of being asset-light, it is exceedingly capital-intensive, and it will depend on market support for endeavours as diverse as lithium mining and wind turbine manufacturing. Or consider a hugely capital-intensive sector: automotive. Original equipment manufacturers (OEMs) are ramping up investment in electric vehicle (EV) technology; One prominent German automaker, for example, has earmarked US$60 billion for a program that could have a significant impact towards emissions reduction.

The returns in such industries often pale in comparison with those in software or payments, however, creating a high barrier to the flow of capital. Consider, again, the auto industry and its investment in EV. Margins are likely to suffer for years until volumes can offset costs. Equity investors are rightfully wary of this phase, during which returns on capital are uncertain. With exception, OEMs must rely on internal cash flow, and will require a considerable transition time during which customers will need to be encouraged to purchase both internal-combustion and EV technologies, as the former funds the latter.

While stock investors may not be inclined to reward companies for their high capital intensity, many bond investors have a different perspective. Demand for green bonds in fixed income markets is strong, and they may become the vehicle of choice to fund capital-intensive projects. Importantly, these instruments have the potential to be ring-fenced (having a defined use of proceeds), timely (duration can be limited) and behavioral (rewards can be embedded for improving environmental performance).

For the financial industry to contribute meaningfully to an energy transition, accelerating the flows to capital-intensive industries is critical. Government incentives and subsidies have a role in this, despite the free-market criticism they often encounter; markets need mechanisms and feedback loops that incentivize both equity and credit investors to fund greener business models. Just as importantly, real progress towards carbon targets will require a rethink of the idea that sustainability and low capital intensity go hand in hand. In reality, there is no free lunch, and we urgently need to alter the incentives driving asset allocation in global markets.

The commentaries contained herein are provided as a general source of information based on information available as of March 5, 2020 and should not be considered as investment advice or an offer or solicitations to buy and/or sell securities. Every effort has been made to ensure accuracy in these commentaries at the time of publication, however, accuracy cannot be guaranteed. Investors are expected to obtain professional investment advice.

The views expressed in this blog are those of the author and do not necessarily represent the opinions of AGF, its subsidiaries or any of its affiliated companies, funds or investment strategies.

AGF Investments is a group of wholly owned subsidiaries of AGF and includes AGF Investments Inc., AGF Investments America Inc., AGF Investments LLC, AGF Asset Management (Asia) Limited and AGF International Advisors Company Limited. The term AGF Investments m ay refer to one or m ore of the direct or indirect subsidiaries of AGF or to all of them jointly. This term is used for convenience and does not precisely describe any of the separate companies, each of which manages its own affairs.

™ The ‘AGF’ logo is a trademark of AGF Management Limited and used under licence.

About AGF Management Limited

Founded in 1957, AGF Management Limited (AGF) is an independent and globally diverse asset management firm. AGF brings a disciplined approach to delivering excellence in investment management through its fundamental, quantitative, alternative and high-net-worth businesses focused on providing an exceptional client experience. AGF’s suite of investment solutions extends globally to a wide range of clients, from financial advisors and individual investors to institutional investors including pension plans, corporate plans, sovereign wealth funds and endowments and foundations.

For further information, please visit AGF.com.

© 2023 AGF Management Limited. All rights reserved.

Written by

Martin Grosskopf

Martin Grosskopf, MBA, MES

Vice-President and Portfolio Manager

AGF Investments Inc.


Andy Kochar

Andy Kochar, CFA®

Vice-President, Portfolio Manager and Head of Global Credit

AGF Investments LLC

More from Martin Grosskopf

  • Investing and Market Views

The Sustainability of Sustainable Investing

May 11, 2020

  • Investing and Market Views

Survey: Investors Increasingly Interested in Responsible Investments, Concerned About Plastic

November 28, 2019

  • Investing and Market Views

Mining an energy transition: Cobalt, the Congo and the responsible investor

October 15, 2019

  • Investing and Market Views

Beyond ‘Greed is Good’

August 28, 2019

Get perspectives straight to your inbox.

Subscribe now

More articles like this

Downshifting Equities to Neutral

  • Investing and Market Views

Downshifting Equities to Neutral

Kevin McCreadie | January 17, 2023

Kevin McCreadie, AGF’s CEO and Chief Investment Officer, discusses the AGF Asset Allocation Committee’s latest quarterly update and the “return to normal.”

Read More
An Alternative(s) Take on the New Year

  • Investing and Market Views

An Alternative(s) Take on the New Year

Ash Lawrence | January 13, 2023

The important role alternative investments can play in support of a 60/40 portfolio.

Read More
Yes, Markets Are Oversold. But Investors Still Need to Be Cautious

  • Investing and Market Views

Yes, Markets Are Oversold. But Investors Still Need to Be Cautious

Abhishek Ashok | November 24, 2022

Every month (or so), AGFiQ highlights the quantitative investment factors that are helping shape equity markets. Today’s focus is oversold conditions and the risk of weakening economic and earnings data.

Read More
AGF Logo
  • Industry and Expert Views
  • Investing and Market Views
  • Capitol Insights
Follow AGF

AGF Web Site Pages © 2023 AGF Management Limited. All rights reserved.

  • Terms & Conditions
  • Privacy
  • AGF.com